The Challenge

The Challenge is an event that has been foretold to happen according to the prophecies of both light, darkness, and a third prophecy. In it, the two chosen ones will each read two books, each giving a conflicting tale of FNAF, and try to determine which book is factual, and which is not. If the correct book is chosen, the chooser gains great power (which was revealed to be Enlightenment), while if the wrong book is chosen, a bad fate is inflicted upon them (Revealed to be getting erased from existence.)

The prophecies disagree on what exactly will happen-The Prophecy of Light and The Book of Twilight both state that one will choose the right book, the other the wrong, while the Prophecy of Darkness states that it's possible both choose the correct book. However, all the prophecies agree that the Challenge will not happen until after Fazbear Fright burns down at the end of 2023.